Touch here for mobile friendly version

Showing posts with label Grist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Grist. Show all posts

Saturday, September 3, 2016

David Roberts of Vox (formerly of Grist) -- Not "Pro-nuclear"

A little history from Grist:

Climate Hawk takes flight

"It is with great sadness but also no small degree of pride that I'm writing to share the news that David Roberts will be leaving Team Grist shortly to join Vox ...

...When he applied to be a news writer at Grist in 2003, he didn't know much about climate change or any issues we covered--I.e., he was a philosophy grad who used to write movie reviews for IMDb--but he definitively knew how to write, so we took a chance on him."

Although he wrote for an environmental website, David does not consider himself to be an environmentalist (whatever exactly that is):














From David's Twitter account:











Why is he compelled to point out that he isn't a doctor? Because, believe it or not, less astute readers out there fairly routinely think the dr in his Twitter moniker stands for doctor instead of David Roberts. There is a Dr David Roberts who writes for Foreign Affairs, so maybe that's part of the confusion but more than likely it's an artifact of a roughly bell-shaped IQ distribution.

Nature just isn't his thing. David's thing is climate change. I don't recall him ever writing about nature in the decade or so he was at Grist. A climate hawk does not "focus on things like land preservation or biodiversity." When put to a vote by Grist readers to pick a term that describes someone who wants to focus on climate change instead of, say, nature, the term Climate Hawk was chosen ...which is somewhat ironic considering that raptor deaths have always been and continue to be a major concern with improperly sited wind farms (not a problem if properly sited). The irony can be taken a step further considering that every self-proclaimed climate hawk I've ever encountered is also antinuclear energy--the second largest source of zero-emission energy on the planet.

Global Zero Emissions Sources of Electricity

Saturday, May 7, 2016

Articles of Interest and Commentary--5/7/2016

 Cross-posted at Energy Trends Insider

Green Tech Media

 

I Was Wrong About the Limits of Solar. PV Is Becoming Dirt Cheap

by David Keith


Although quite upbeat about solar PV (and I'm also a big fan of solar PV), this article generated almost 300 comments because it was also frank about the limits of solar PV, and wind, and to make matters worse, he concluded the article with the following statement:
My view is that only two forms of energy -- solar and nuclear power -- can plausibly supply tens of terawatts without a huge environmental impact.
This is tantamount to blasphemy in most green (whatever exactly that means) technology websites. Which explains much of the action in the comment field but one comment in particular by Susan Kraemer caught my attention. She feels that CSP (concentrated solar power) with molten salt for heat storage is the answer to solar intermittency. I found this interesting because she had recently written an article at Earth Techling titled How a Hotter Climate Destroys Thermal Electricity Generation. CSP is thermal electricity generation (spins turbines with hot gases and must dump waste heat). The irony (is that the right word?) is that I had explained this to her in a comment under her article:
Thermal power simply becomes less efficient. It will be no more "destroyed" than solar photo voltaic:

"As part of Power System Program of the International Energy Agency (EIA), a study was conducted to analyze data from 18 grid connected PV plants located on different geographic locations and it showed a direct relation between temperature and PV module efficiency. The plants were located in Austria, German, Italy, Japan and Switzerland. The study concluded that 17 out of the 18 systems showed annual losses in efficiency due to temperature changes by 1.7% to 11.3%."

Also, solar thermal power plants have the same efficiency loss as any other thermal power source.

So, that leaves wind. Nobody is planning to run civilization only on wind. The future will be some mix of wind, solar, hydro, and nuclear with just enough natural gas to stitch them all together. The fact that higher temperatures will reduce efficiency is just something engineers will compensate for, and the lower efficiency would, all things being equal, result in higher prices, but I suspect the price difference will be negligible.
...you can lead a horse to water.

But the the study she wrote about also pointed out that hydro, the undisputed king of renewable energy, is going to be in a world of hurt. There are a lot of environmental bloggers out there without any kind of engineering background who write about energy issues, and the fact that they don't always understand the engineering principles behind what they write is obvious, at least to an engineer.

VOX

VOX doesn't allow comment under its articles. I try to make it a policy not to provide links for (or usually even read) articles without comment fields under them. Comment fields go a long way to keep blog authors honest. Would you buy stuff on Amazon from a retailer that does not allow reviews of their products? Me either. Why should you have to buy what an author says without seeing what reviewers think? I'm making an exception in this case because I'm essentially providing a comment field for these articles and anyone is welcome to participate.

Two articles by Dave Roberts caught my attention.

Saturday, May 19, 2012

How Much Are You Willing to Pay for Clean Energy?


 Cross-posted from Renewable Energy Report

A recent study published in the subscription only Nature Climate Change (which I do not have a subscription for) found the price Americans are willing to pay to have 80 percent "clean" energy by 2035. Drum roll please  ...$13 bucks a month.

The researchers went a step further and calculated that the cost would have to drop even further to overcome political barriers:
"The researchers — Joseph E. Aldy, Matthew J. Kotchen and Anthony A. Leiserowitz — ran a what-if exercise and found the current level of public support insufficient to overcome entrenched opposition in Congress.
Majority rule does not really apply there, of course: getting anything controversial through the Senate, for example, requires 60 votes to break filibusters. With some number-crunching and assumptions about how preferences back home would influence the votes of lawmakers, the researchers found that the annual added cost per household of a clean energy policy would have to drop below $59 a year to pass the current Senate and below $48 a year to pass the current House."

Ignore for a moment the fact that there is no consensus as to what constitutes a clean energy source. The survey also assumed that 80 percent "clean" energy was technologically and economically feasible, which is about as useful as asking people how much they would be willing to pay to vacation on Mars.

Their willingness to pay declined if nuclear or natural gas were included in the definition of "clean." Not having access to the full study, and judging by the name of the journal, I am assuming that by clean, they meant sources that produce the least amount of greenhouse gases:

 
Justin Gillis of the NYT interprets this to mean that ...

"If we are going to bother with it at all, the public seems to feel, we might as well go deep green."

Riiight  ...deep green, whatever that means. Almost all "deep green" energy today, depending on definition, comes from the combustion of plant material and the damming of river ecosystems. Scaling either one up will exacerbate the extinction crisis. Read Will mega-dams destroy the Amazon? Then read Wildlife in the tropics plummets by over 60 percent.

Over the last 20 years renewable energy in the U.S. has gone from 11% of our mix to 10%. From How wind power fits into our energy diet:

 
The Natural Resources Defense Council and the Sierra Club have recently joined forces to try to stop a solar project in California:

"...the Calico project covers 4,000 plus acres of important wildlife habitat in the Pisgah Valley, including key desert tortoise habitat.  Building this solar power plant would also threaten at least six other imperiled species such as burrowing owls, golden eagles, Mojave fringe-toed lizards, Nelson’s bighorn sheep and several rare plants."

Photo courtesy of j03via Flickr

Monday, April 30, 2012

Nuclear Energy is Not a Mature Industry

Article originally appeared at Consumer Energy Report

Senator Bernie Sanders is using Grist Magazine to lobby against government assistance for nuclear energy on the grounds that it's a mature industry. I might agree with him if it really were a mature industry and if renewables really could carry the day without it. But it isn't, and renewables can't. Always irritates me to watch ignorant politicians screw with my children's' futures. As sometimes happens with my long-winded comments, the one I left over there got large enough to convert into a post over here.

Senator Sanders may have good intentions, but what's new? We don't need any more roads to hell paved by those. He's just another member of the generation that has been systematically misinformed by "the end justifies the means" anti-nuclear lobby and our sensationalist for profit lay media.

An earlier article on Grist recently (and inadvertently) demonstrated with a simple graph that the most optimistic estimates for renewable energy do not come close to meeting our energy needs, all cost issues aside.

Do government subsidies ever pay off? The poster child for government subsidies that have paid off royally would have to be those for nuclear energy. There are presently about 60 nuclear power plants under construction around the world. Just off the press:
Westinghouse Electric Company and Ameren Missouri have entered into an agreement to respond collaboratively to the United States Department of Energy (DOE) Funding Opportunity Announcement (FOA) for developing and licensing the Westinghouse Small Modular Reactor (SMR).
Bernie and/or his co-writer said:
Whether you support nuclear energy or not, we should all be able to agree that with record debt, we cannot afford to continue to subsidize this mature industry and its multi-billion-dollar corporations. If the nuclear industry believes so fervently in its technology, then nuclear companies and Wall Street investors can put their money where the mouth is. Let them finance, insure, and pay for nuclear plants themselves.
I can't think of a more promising technology to subsidize. With all of the new nuclear technology coming down the road, you can't seriously call this a mature industry. Where's the legislation to end government mandated consumption of food-based corn ethanol (moonshine) which may quietly be starving hundreds of thousands to death annually?

Nuclear may be expensive up front, but it certainly has proven to pay off over time. I'm a big fan of renewables, but they are going to need a lot of help from nuclear, and never mind that renewables receive even greater subsidies and are even more expensive than nuclear per unit energy, not that this is necessarily a bad thing.

Nuclear energy has been around for about half of a century. Aircraft technology has been around for about a century. By Senator Sander’s reasoning, a Sopwith Camel is the equivalent of an F-22 Raptor. There would be no F-22 raptor without government funding.

Friday, July 16, 2010

Response To The Cornucopians


(Photo credit: Ollie Crafoord's photo stream Flickr)

There have been four recent articles in Grist (mine makes the fifth and I would not blame anyone for not bothering to read it) on the topic of population. I put it together mostly as a matter of record. Good luck keeping track of it all. I list them below in chronological order:

1) On World Population Day, take note: population isn’t the problem by Fred Pearce.

2) To the population doomsayers: What do you propose? by Jason D Scorse.

3) Of course population is still a problem by Robert Walker.

4) Response to the population doomsayers and Robert Walker by Jason D Scorse.

5) Response To The Cornucopians by Me.

Fred's article (1) contains the words doom, doomed, doomsday, doom-mongers, and doomsters. Jason jumped on (2,4) the band wagon adding the word "doomsayer."

Victory in the struggle to reign in our human population growth by Fred's and Jason's "doomsters and doomsayers" is in sight. Someday in the next several decades it will peak and start a decline. No demographer worth her salt would bet her first born on what that final number will be, but when it finally happens, a new struggle will ensue to allow it to decline, which will have to be fought by a new generation of "doomsters."

Sustainable consumption has been a target of the environmental community since day one. Environmentalists of Fred's age have been recycling for decades. Do we need to accelerate our efforts? You bet. Especially as more and more people come out of poverty and can afford to buy more. Can we now ignore population concerns? Not in your life.

Who would you guess was most likely responsible for the annihilation of Easter Island's ecosystem, their doomsayers or their cornucorpians?

Essentially, Fred is saying that all of you out there who limited family size, or even adopted a child, in part to ease the burden on the planet, are a bunch of dupes. There is no need to limit your family size if you are concerned about the impacts of a larger family size on the environment. If you have five kids, consume five times less.

Just don't tell that to my next-door neighbors who recently adopted an AIDS orphan from Ethiopia.

There are about as many unicorns on this planet as there are eugenics fruitlogs calling for population culls. Fred is tilting at windmills (attacking imaginary enemies).

Fred's claim is that population not a problem, but slips up several times where he suggests that maybe it is--just not as big a problem as consumption. He does not grasp the concept that it does not matter which is the bigger problem; they are both big problems.

Without the industrial revolution, childhood mortality, warfare, pestilence, and starvation would still rule population growth. If we were all subsistence farmers, there wouldn't be a tree or elephant left on the planet. The elephants would have been eaten and the wood burned as fuel long ago. In other words, subsistence farming may not contribute as much carbon to the atmosphere, but that lifestyle is obviously capable of doing as much damage to the planet as the rest of us living in industrial societies. India and China certainly managed to devastate their ecosystems without being "rich."

Fred focuses on carbon emissions, but our problems are much bigger than that.

Lincoln's log cabin may have used as much lumber as my house. As wood became scarcer, logs were cut into planks, and eventually peeled to make plywood. Now, forests are harvested and immediately replanted. Sustainable consumption has been a goal for environmentalists, along with population concerns, which are part of the same equation, since day one.

Part of Fred's schtick is to cite fertility statistics that the environmental community has been familiar with for decades as if they have been well-kept secrets, but fails to mention the recent statistical finding that the number of chronically hungry human beings has crossed a billion souls for the first time in human history. Holding hands, they would wrap around the planet about thirty times (assuming four-foot spacing). Go figure.

Below, Jason defends his use of the term doomsayer in his post (4):

"Doomsayers" is an appropriate term for many of those who think population is a huge problem.


How big is "huge" and if doomsayer is an appropriate term, it applies to everyone who thinks population is a "huge" problem, not just to "many."

My take is that doomsayer is a derogatory term being used to describe individuals who feel that there is a real likelihood that the accelerating extinction event will continue unabated and that humanity may experience a massive and marked degradation in quality of life as natural resource limits are passed that we cannot compensate for with technology (like plywood in place of old growth trees) thanks to the combination of growing consumption and population. The term derides the likes of David Suzuki, Lester Brown, E.O. Wilson, David Attenborough, and the list could go on and on.

As stated earlier, the number of chronically hungry human beings has passed a billion for the first time in human history, holding hands, they would wrap around the planet about thirty times. Huge?

On the other hand, Rush Limbaugh likes to point out that every human on the planet could fit inside the state of Texas with room to spare--making it the world's largest cemetery I might add.

The USDA quietly reported a few weeks ago that despite world record harvests for the last three years, we have been using corn for ethanol, exports, and food faster than we can grow it since 2006/7 and have been drawing down reserves to meet demand since that time. Understand that the market will eventually respond to the higher price that shortages command with even more planting. Also understand that a corn field is just one species away from being as biologically impoverished as a mall parking lot. We focus lately on global warming but according to a study published in Nature this year, it is mostly this expansion of human agriculture that is destroying the biosphere.

Here are just a few recent articles making the case, in an unending line of such articles that stretch over the horizon, appearing daily if you have the stomach to look for them:

Will Anything Curb China’s Appetite for Rare Wildlife?

Amazon river dolphins being slaughtered for bait

Africa's national parks not working properly

Wild tiger population falls 97% since turn of the century (there are about 3000 tigers left in the wild (almost a quarter of a million people are added to the earth every day--221,000, 76 million per year) and 1000 pure bred tigers also in captivity (the rest are essentially mutts).

Jason goes on to say:

...nowhere do I see more apocalyptic and defeastist rhetoric in the environmental movement.


Certainly, anyone who fits the definition of his above derogatory label would find these remarks somewhat offensive. As I posited earlier, who would you guess was most likely culpable for the annihilation of Easter Island's ecosystem, their "doomsayers" or their cornucorpians?

There's a new book out called The Rational Optimist--How Prosperity Evolves by Matt Ridley. Go here to see George Monbiot's critique of Ridley's economic views. You can see my review of it here. In that review I posited the following analogy:

The "doomsters" are the ones standing next to the captain on the bridge helping to spot icebergs so she can take action to avoid them, while the cornucopians continue to party in the ballroom, deriding the doomsters on the bridge. If they arrive safely in port the conucorpians will use that fact as proof the doomsters were wrong, that the ship will likely never strike an iceberg, and if it should, won't sink. They are free riders--to borrow a term from economics.

Ridley is a popular science writer and it was his endorsement of Bjorn Lomborg's book The Skeptical Environmentalist back in 2001 (recently deconstructed in a book called The Lomborg Deception by Howard Friel) that helped make it so popular.

Jason says:

There really aren't that many other policies proposed [other than promoting women's reproductive rights] by the "population is the problem" side because there are very few other options that aren't extremely coercive.


Population is "a big" problem. Maintaining vigilance, along with accelerated and improved support of women's reproductive rights is what today's population activists, excuse me, doomsayers, promote. In addition, they promote via education, the advantages of smaller family size.

There are 40 million pregnancy termination procedures performed annually around the world. Had the religionists won that struggle we would have about 12 billion people right now. We don't want them to win that struggle in the future either. Imagine them gaining ground on their efforts to end the use of contraception, to promote ever larger (pick a religious cult) families.

It is my opinion that the United States baby boom was a fad, like SUVs. It could return in some form if women get it in their heads again that the cool kids have larger families. It's already starting to happen in wealthier circles, where having three kids is assumed to be cooler than one or two.

Fred and Jason appear to be under the impression that the peak population number is already set in stone.

Fred and Jason are not population experts. There is tremendous room for improvement (half of all pregnancies in the United States are unplanned) and the number is not set in stone.

According to Joel Cohen in his book "How Many People Can The Earth Support" nobody has successfully predicted what the human population would be a decade in advance.

Jason asked readers what they thought the optimum population should be:

...these people basically think it would be best if 2/3 to 3/4 of the planet's people were wiped out.


Actually not. It was a hypothetical question and he conveniently failed to ask readers how they thought this optimum population could be obtained, or if it could be obtained, or when it could be obtained, so he could answer for them as shown above.

Clearly for the long term, the question of optimum population size is academic--water under the bridge. That does not mean that humanity won't one day strive for a much lower population by maintaining lower replacement rates.

Jason goes on:

...there is no compelling scientific evidence that I have seen that says that 9 billion people can't enjoy a high standard of living and maintain earth's life support.


...says the economist as the extinction event rages unabated. There is no compelling scientific evidence that I have seen that says that 9 billion people can enjoy a high standard of living and maintain earth's life support.

Like global warming, its a probability game with the odds being skewed by population size. The bigger the size the less likely we will stave off degradation.

E.O. Wilson summed the idea up best when he said:

"The race is now on between the technoscientific and scientific forces that are destroying the living environment and those that can be harnessed to save it ...


Next, Jason concludes:

And since I don't want to advocate the demise of the majority of the world's people, I will stick with this side of the equation


And because nobody is advocating the demise of the majority of the world's people, Jason's essay is just as much of a strawman as Fred's was.

Jason goes on to point out a fact known by everyone for decades, that there is hypothetically enough food on this planet to feed everyone, its a simple matter of getting it better distributed.

But he's wrong again. It's a matter of affordability.

For example, by getting enough obese people to diet, the supply of food will increase causing the price of food will drop, allowing the poor to afford more of it. Good luck with that idea.

Food affordability is a function of supply and demand. The demand is driven in large part by the quarter of a million humans added to the population every single day. Facts like "half of American pregnancies are unplanned" are why that number remains so high.

Let's use water as an analogy for food. We all know there is also enough water on this planet to quench everyone's thirst. The problem comes down to this; who pays to move the water to where the thirsty people are?

Population pressures exacerbate problems of all kinds, making it more difficult or impossible to solve them.

His concluding statement:

It's how we live, not how many of us there are, that will determine our and the planet's fate.


No. It's the combination of both and there are no guarantees. The last thing we need is to relax efforts to reduce population growth. "Sensible" environmentalists know that efforts to improve what and how we consume are important as well as efforts to reduce population growth.

So far I've concentrated on critiquing the article Jason piggybacked onto Fred's.

Fred hawks decades-old fertility data as if it were something new. And indeed, it may be new to a few people who have not read anything on the subject since Ehrlichs' book The Population Bomb published in 1968.

A green myth is on the march. It wants to blame the world's overbreeding poor people for the planet's peril.


Strawman #1. I could probably count the number of environmentalists who blame "...the world's overbreeding poor people for the planet's peril" on one hand.

Some greens think all efforts to save the world are doomed unless we "do something" about continuing population growth. But this is nonsense. Worse, it is dangerous nonsense.


Strawman #2. We are doing something about population growth by promoting smaller families. How could anyone call that nonsense and worse yet, dangerous? Wouldn't it be more dangerous to run around spreading the word that family size is irrelevant?

For a start, the population bomb that I remember being scared by 40 years ago as a schoolkid is being defused fast.


Maybe Fred has been living under a rock for forty years, but it has been well known for decades that fertility rates have been dropping and that the number of people added to the planet every year has been less than the preceding year since about 1989.

Although the percentage of population growth began to decrease in 1968 (ironically the year the Ehrlichs' book The Population Bomb was published) from about 2.08 percent to about 2.05 percent (see chart below), the actual number of people being added every year continued to increase as a result of population momentum, reaching a peak of about 87 million in 1989. Again, by coincidence, this was the same year that the Ehrlichs' book The Population Explosion was published and also marked the start of a decline in the number of people added every year that continues to this day.



Figure 1: Population Data
Source: U.S. Bureau of the Census, International Database.

In theory, Fred could have taken credit for discovering that the population bomb was "defused" two decades ago.

Women are cutting their family sizes not because governments tell them to, but for their own good and the good of their families...


Ah, you forgot about China, a land of 1.3 billion people. And Iran's family planning is government sponsored as well, although voluntary.


...and if it helps the planet too, then so much the better.


And if it helps the planet too? Translation--those of you who have chosen a smaller family size in part to limit the stress on the biosphere are idiots.

Didn't Fred just tell us that population growth concerns are dangerous nonsense? And who does he think it was who planted the idea (started the meme) that smaller families are better for all involved, including the planet?

This is a stunning change in just one generation. Why don't we hear more about it? Because it doesn't fit the doomsday agenda.


Again, has Fred been living in a cave somewhere? This is old news. And the doomsday agenda hypothesis, that's just bullshit.

Half the world now has fewer than the "replacement level" of children.


And you can thank the doomsayers for that, not the cornucorpians. World population is poised to cross seven billion in about 2 years growing at a rate of about 76 million per year.

Yes, Iran. Women in Tehran today have fewer children than their sisters in New York -- and a quarter as many as their mothers had.


This story is also twenty years old. Iran’s reduction in fertility rates was done entirely through non-coercive "government sponsored" family planning and education of both men and women with very little change in income levels.

And China. There, the communist government decides how many children couples can have. The one-child policy is brutal and repulsive.


Millions of starving people is what I would call brutal and repulsive. China's efforts to reduce fertility rates has prevented the birth of about as many people as now live in the United States and those efforts haven't been limited to the one child policy. Forming a perspective on that policy by reading sensationalist newspaper articles about the abuses is not a the best way to understand it:

Moreover, in accordance with PRC's affirmative action policies towards ethnic minorities, all non-Han ethnic groups are subjected to different rules and are usually allowed to have two children in urban areas, and three or four in rural areas. Han Chinese living in rural areas, also, are often permitted to have two children.[22] Because of couples such as these, as well as urban couples who simply pay a fine (or "social maintenance fee") to have more children,[23] the overall fertility rate of mainland China is closer to two children per family than to one child per family (1.8). The steepest drop in fertility occurred in the 1970s before one child per family was implemented in 1979. Population policies and campaigns have been ongoing in China since the 1950s. During the 1970s, a campaign of 'One is good, two is okay, and three is too many' was heavily promoted.[24]

In April 2007 a study by the University of California, Irvine, which claimed to be the first systematic study of the policy, found that it had proved "remarkably effective"


Fred continues:

But the odd thing is that it may not make much difference any more. Chinese women round the world have gone the same way without compulsion.

...Britain wasn't running a covert one-child policy. That was as many children as the women in Hong Kong wanted.


How brutal and repulsive can the one child policy really be, if Chinese women have been reducing fertility regardless of its existence--both inside and outside of China?

What is going on? Family-planning experts used to say that women only started having fewer children when they got educated or escaped poverty -- like us. But tell that to the women of Bangladesh.


Ever hear of a thing called a meme, Fred? This particular meme, that smaller families are achievable and often preferred, spread across the world thanks to environmentalists and women's reproductive rights proponents, who make up a large part of the audience you keep insulting with this article. That meme was propagated by this audience.

The local joke is that they prefer being sterilized to other methods of contraception because you only have to confess once. It may not be a joke.


I doubt it is a joke. Imagine undergoing a tubal ligation to avoid dealing with your local religionist male authorities. And again, your doomsters are largely responsible for spreading the ideas that have allowed women to take control of family size, even if it takes elective abdominal surgery! Abortion is still illegal there.

Women are having smaller families because, for the first time in history, they can. Because we have largely eradicated the diseases that used to mean most children died before growing up. Mothers no longer need to have five or six children to ensure the next generation, so they don't.


It's not that simple, Fred. You showed earlier that economists are often wrong when they cobble together excuses for fertility trends in hindsight (your poor women in India, and Iran). This is another case of them being largely wrong. The American baby boom is all the evidence you need to water down that explanation. My mom had six kids, my wife's mom had five--back in the day when a blue-collar worker could support a spouse and five kids.

There are holdouts, of course. In parts of rural Africa, women still have five or more children. But even here they are being rational -- they need the kids to mind the animals and work in the fields.


Wrong again, Fred. African women are not consciously breeding farm hands. There are more than enough farm hands in Africa. Rational isn't the term I'd use to describe someone who has ten kids that will all need their own plots of land to farm for their families. If half of the pregnancies here are unplanned, you can bet that poor African women are mostly overwhelmed by obstacles that prevent them from better controlling family size.

The big story is that rich or poor, socialist or capitalist, Muslim or Catholic, secular or devout, with tough government birth-control policies or none, most countries tell the same story: Small families are the new norm.


This is a good example of what I meant when I said that Fred seems to think this has all been kept a big secret by some unnamed authority. This isn't news, Fred. This is modern history.

That doesn't mean women don't still need help to achieve their ambitions of small families. They need governments or charities to distribute modern contraception. But this is now about rights for women, not "population control."


Earlier in the article Fred said "Women are cutting their family sizes not because governments tell them to" and here he says governments distribute contraceptives--a government "suggesting" what they should do, as is done all over the world, including Iran, China, India to varying degrees.

Fred's inaccurate and inflammatory "population control" term is abused by religionists all over the world to fight against women's reproductive rights.


This is good news for the environment [that the world's population may begin a slow decrease sometime in the next half century, but not necessarily in the next generation]. But don't put out the flags. Another myth put out by the population doom-mongers is that it's all those extra people that are wrecking the planet. But that's no longer the case.


The above text is another of Fred's contradictions, where he simultaneously tells us that less population growth is and is not good news for the environment.

Rising consumption today is a far bigger threat to the environment than a rising head count. And most of that extra consumption is still happening in rich countries that have long since given up growing their populations.


Again he contradicts himself. He concedes that a rising head count is a threat. The argument about which is the bigger threat is irrelevant.

Virtually all of the remaining population growth is in the poor world, and the poor half of the planet is only responsible for 7 percent of carbon emissions.


I doubt that is true, not that it matters, and it isn't just about carbon emissions.

Visualize the world today with 6.7 billion people on it, all living the life of an African subsistence farmer. Would the world be better off? It just isn't that simple. First, there would not be 6.7 billion people. Without the industrial revolution, childhood mortality, warfare, pestilence, and starvation would still rule population growth. And if there were 6.7 billion subsistence farmers, there wouldn't be a tree or elephant left on the planet. The elephants would have been eaten and the wood burned as fuel. The bushmeat trade, tiger, rhino, and elephant poaching have poured gas on the extinction event. It all adds up. The planet is bleeding to death from 6.7 billion cuts.

This blame game does not work for me. All human beings are driven by the same instincts, subconscious urges.

According to a report issued by the FAO last year, livestock (much of it owned by the poor) accounts for roughly 18% of global warming. This chart shows how that impact is distributed, which is driven mostly by land use changes. Soot accounts for about 18% of global warming. Here is a recent article in the New York Times discussing where much of that soot is coming from. Deforestation accounts for about a third of global warming, which is being driven by demand for meat and wood by people rising up out of poverty as well as biofuels. Who is more to blame? The poor person logging the lumber or the rich person he is selling it to, the ivory poacher or the rich person he is selling it to (and both would do the same if their role switched)?


Some greens need to take a long, hard look at themselves. They should remember where some of their ideas came from.


Here Fred slams about 99 percent of the people who consider themselves a "green." He's telling them that their family planning decisions have been in vain. Those of you who limited family size to save the planet, or even adopted a child, well, population growht is not a concern. It was a gargantuan mistake to have limited your family size based on environmental concerns.

The granddaddy of demographic doomsters was Bob Malthus, an English clergyman who got famous by warning 200 years ago about population growth. He believed that the world's population would keep increasing till it was cut down by disease or famine. Back in the ferment of the Industrial Revolution, he was a favorite of the evil mill owners and a scourge on anyone with a social conscience.


Above Fred tries to use Malthus (a religionist) to denigrate by association population/women's reproductive rights activists (who nowadays are indistinguishable). May I point out that Rush Limbaugh could not agree more with Fred.

But in doing so, he also denigrates the likes of Darwin, who incorporated many of the ideas presented by Malthus. Freud blew it with the penis envy thing but got many things right. Darwin was wrong on several things, as was Leonardo di ser Piero da Vinci, Karl Marx, and on and on and on.

I think Karl Marx, another contemporary, was spot on when he called Malthusian ideas "a libel on the human race."


Yeah, well, Karl Marx was less than spot on when one considers the millions who have suffered as a result of attempts to force his Utopian concept of communism onto an intensely hierarchical social primate species with a propensity to go to war at the drop of a hat.

The population bomb is being defused right now -- by the world's poor women. Sadly, the consumption bomb is still primed and ever more dangerous. Now that would be a proper target for environmentalists.


Ah, no. The defusing has been ongoing for decades, and certainly not by just the poor women of the world. The concept of sustainable consumption is just as old as the concept that small family sizes are better for the planet. The idea that we will concentrate more on the consumption side of the equation by ignoring the population side is disingenuous.